How do betting exchanges actually make money?
ok so ive been using betfair for a few weeks now after years on normal bookies and i dont get it. theres no margin built into the odds like with bookmakers right? so how are they actually making cash off me. is the commission really enough or am i missing something here
▲
56
11 answers
Top Answer
yeah the commission is literally the whole business model. they dont care who wins or loses cos theyre just matching backers against layers. they take a cut of your net winnings on each market, usually around 2-5% depending on the platform. i jumped between a couple before settling, used Rolletto for a while and the commission was lower than betfair which made a real difference when youre grinding small margins. the genius of it is theyre not exposed to any risk at all, win or lose they get paid either way
▲
131
can confirm, this is exactly it. been using exchanges for like 3 years and once it clicked it made total sense. the bookies take risk on every bet, the exchange takes zero. they just sit in the middle and clip the ticket. honestly its a cleaner model imo
▲
95
fwiw the commission is only ever charged on your net winnings in a market, not on every single bet. so if you lose you dont pay commission on that. people forget that bit
▲
6
also worth mentioning some exchanges do tiered commission. the more you bet the lower your rate goes in theory but tbh most casual punters never hit those tiers. theres also premium charges on betfair if you win too much consistently which is its own can of worms
▲
67
The basic mechanism is that an exchange is essentially a marketplace. Backers and layers set their own prices and the exchange matches them. The house never participates in the wager itself, it just facilitates and charges a transaction fee on settled profits. Same principle as a stock exchange really.
▲
40
read somewhere that they also make a bit on the float, like holding everyones deposited funds. not sure how significant that is compared to commission but it adds up at scale i suppose
▲
45
the thing nobody warns you about is the premium charge. i did well for a season on betfair and suddenly they start taking up to 60% of my profits cos apparently i was too successful. so dont think exchanges are some risk free paradise for the punter, they absolutely will claw it back if you actually win
▲
52
↳
yeah the premium charge is brutal but tbf it only hits a tiny fraction of users who are genuinely smashing it long term. for normal punters and even most matched bettors you never come close to triggering it. didnt have that issue on the smaller exchanges i used, only really a betfair thing because of their dominance
▲
4
wait so if theres no margin in the odds does that mean the odds are actually better than a regular bookie? or am i misunderstanding how this works
▲
26
↳
yeah generally the odds are better, sometimes noticeably so, especially on bigger markets with lots of liquidity. even after you pay commission youre often still getting more value than a bookmakers price. thats the whole appeal. on obscure markets with no money matched though the prices can be rubbish or you cant get matched at all
▲
7
can vouch for everything said here. switched from bookies a couple years back mainly cos i kept getting my accounts limited the second i won anything. on an exchange they cant limit you for winning, they just take their commission and move on. way less stressful even if the interface took me ages to figure out
▲
23