Grealish's Injury Leaves Everton Facing Tough $90 Million Transfer Decision

What was meant to be Jack Grealish's comeback tale at Everton has taken an unexpected turn. The English midfielder, who fell out of the rotation at Manchester City, joined the Toffees on loan for the 2025/26 campaign with expectations running high on both sides.

The opening month looked promising. Grealish recorded four assists in August alone, earning him the Premier League Player of the Month honours. However, the momentum hasn't continued. Over his next 22 appearances, he's managed only two goals and two assists – figures that fall short of expectations for a player commanding substantial wages.

The situation has become even more complicated. Grealish has suffered a foot injury that could keep him out for the remainder of the season. This development puts Everton management in an awkward position regarding the $90 million CAD buy option included in his loan agreement.

Is the Investment Worth It?

Credit where it's due – Grealish has been saying the right things publicly. He's expressed that he's fallen back in love with the game under David Moyes. Following his match-winning goal against Bournemouth last month, he was effusive in his praise for the manager.

"I love the manager to pieces," Grealish stated. "How he makes me feel, how he makes me want to play for him - credit to him." These are genuine words from someone who appears to have found his comfort zone.

However, emotional connection doesn't always translate to smart business decisions. Six assists and two goals across 22 matches isn't disastrous, but it hardly justifies $90 million CAD plus significant wages. Factor in that he'll be 31 years old come September, and the calculus becomes even trickier.

Everton's attacking options haven't done him any favours. Forwards Beto and Thierno Barry have combined for just seven goals this campaign. It's reasonable to wonder whether Grealish's statistics would improve with more clinical finishers alongside him. Still, that's a hefty $90 million CAD gamble for the Toffees.

If Everton can negotiate that figure downward and convince Grealish to accept reduced wages, making the move permanent could work. Otherwise, the club might need to thank him for his service and explore other options. For those following Everton's summer transfer window, this situation will definitely be one to watch.

Could MLS Be Next?

Should Everton decline to exercise their option, Grealish won't lack for suitors. The slower tempo of Serie A would complement his playing style beautifully. Clubs like AC Milan and Napoli would presumably show interest.

Saudi Pro League teams certainly have the financial resources to lure him to the Gulf region. But would someone who's just rekindled his passion for football really want to move to a less competitive environment?

This is where Major League Soccer enters the conversation. With the 2026 World Cup heading to Canada, the United States, and Mexico, North American soccer is poised for massive growth. The league requires high-profile names who can still perform at a high level, not just aging stars looking for a paycheque.

Grealish checks all those boxes. He still possesses quality, brings name value, and would genuinely elevate MLS squads. While it doesn't carry the prestige of the Premier League, it's a competitive environment where he could excel and rediscover his enjoyment of the sport.

Whether his future lies at Goodison Park, San Siro, or a modern MLS venue, Grealish's next move promises to be intriguing. Meanwhile, Everton faces a significant decision about that purchase option.