Liverpool Legend Steve Nicol Puts Historic Medals and Match-Worn Jerseys Up for Auction

Four league championships. Three FA Cups. A European Cup. The Football Writers' Footballer of the Year trophy. Steve Nicol accumulated silverware the way most defenders rack up bookings — consistently — and now he's offering them to collectors.

The former Liverpool and Ayr United defender, now 64, has teamed up with Propstore to sell more than 50 pieces from his illustrious playing days, with online bidding currently active and a live auction scheduled to conclude on May 14, 2026.

The collection highlights

The star item is his FA Cup Winners' Medal from the 1985-86 campaign, valued between £10,000 and £20,000. Liverpool defeated Everton 3-1 at Wembley that afternoon — Rush and Johnston finding the net — with Nicol completing the full match. This isn't merely a medal; it represents an artifact from Liverpool's final period of true dominance in English football.

His European Cup Winners' Medal from 1984 is estimated at £8,000 to £16,000. Roma, the Stadio Olimpico, a penalty shootout. Liverpool's fourth European Cup triumph. The details remain iconic.

The collection also features his match-worn jersey from the 1989 FA Cup Final (estimated £3,000 to £6,000), another Merseyside clash at Wembley that finished 3-2, plus his Football Writers' Association Footballer of the Year Award from that identical campaign (estimated £2,000 to £4,000). International jerseys from his Scotland days complete the offering, particularly memorable for those who recall Nicol competing at the 1986 World Cup.

Nicol recorded 468 appearances for Liverpool, contributing 46 goals from defensive and midfield positions, and proved dependable enough to slot into virtually any role without causing concern. That type of adaptability rarely receives proper recognition — it simply becomes expected until it disappears.

Life beyond playing: coaching and broadcasting

Following his playing career, Nicol served a decade as head coach of Major League Soccer's New England Revolution, claimed Coach of the Year accolades, and has remained a prominent voice on ESPN's football coverage ever since. Two successful careers. One remarkable collection.

"These pieces carry numerous personal memories," Nicol explained, "but I'm happy to make them available through Propstore, where they'll find homes with supporters and collectors who appreciate that same love for the sport."

Propstore specialist Alastair McCrea stated it clearly: "Material of this caliber and authenticity rarely becomes available." He's accurate. Medals from Liverpool's commanding 1980s era don't appear on the market frequently — and when they do, the valuations typically prove conservative.

The complete catalogue is accessible at propstoreauction.com. Online, absentee, and telephone bidding options are all offered.